On-line retailing is competitive. New start up businesses or bricks and mortar businesses will look at competitors in their field and see what they are up too. It is only natural.
Many retailers (eBayers are the most prolific for this) think that simply copying their competitors will achieve results. So here is a list of considerations before you become a carbon copy of your favourite competitor:
- The element you are copying – does your competitor publish results on its effectiveness?
- Has your competitor analysed the behaviour of your customer base and applied it to that element?
- Is your competitor just ‘guessing’?
- Does your competitor monitor their data and evolve overtime? Or are you copying an archaic element that they keep meaning to change?
Most retailers like to keep this kind of information close to their chest, so in reality you will probably not be able to make decisions based on accurate, tried and tested methods. You are just hoping that what you competitor does, is correct.
But lets turn it on its head a little – why do you have to look at your competitors? Retailers outside your category would have exhibited great ideas too and methods that could be changed/modified to apply to your category.
Let pull this to some examples – Sainsbury’s *feed your family for a fiver* campaign – sales went through the roof and Sainsbury’s did very well out of it. Marks and Spencer’s *Two dine in for* promotions – still compete with Sainsbury’s but this promotion suits the M&S food buyers. Same rough idea – two applications – two different markets.
Now, Somerfield/Co-op are trying to feed four for £4 – which on checking out this deal it is in fact a poor copy of the Sainsbury’s idea – trying to coat tail off the campaign success but just no banana!
So before you just become that carbon copy, remember that on the net we are striving for personalisation in many aspects – so don’t just be content to imitate!
Competitors will always be inspiration, but be that one on-line store that really speaks to its customers, because you have strived to collect the data and listened. You might end up with the same results as a competitor, but at least you will know why they do what they do!













1 response so far ↓
1 Liz // Feb 16, 2010 at 3:39 pm
From an email:
I wanted to say that I’ve spoken to eBay staff about some of eBay’s biggest and best-known sellers, and those staff agreed with me that those sellers make sales IN SPITE OF their templates and listing design, not because of them. Yet, sellers think they just have to copy what that seller is using for listing design, not understanding that there are elements there that mostly don’t work. The big guy is probably making sales because of feedback, pricing, and selection. The template could hurt him, but people are buying anyway.
Take the feedback, pricing, and selection away, and drop the same template in for someone else, and the problems and distracting elements are still there! We should NOT be copying other sellers’ templates, designs, or layouts when in many cases, these are hurting the natural process of how shoppers move around a page.
Deb – http://www.aswas.com
*comments open on this thread now too!
Leave a Comment